When an Ethnographer met Edward Snowden

Published 18 Oct. 2013 at Freedom to Tinker.

If you talk about ‘metadata’, ‘big data’ and ‘Big Brother’ just as easily as you order a pizza, ethnography and anthropology are probably not your first points of reference. But the outcome of a recent encounter of ethnographer Tom Boellstorff and Edward Snowden (not IRL but IRP), is that tech policy wonks and researchers should be careful with their day to day vocabulary, as concepts carry politics of control and power.

In ‘Making big data, in theory’, ethnographer and anthropologist Tom Boellstorff discusses Edward Snowden’s revelations IRP (In Research Paper). The paper, published on 7 October, is a refreshing 12 page take on the construction of some very dominant concepts in tech policy and research today.

Take the concept of ‘metadata’. In support of intelligence programs disclosed by Snowden, proponents claim that one of the most controversial programs is just about ‘metadata’ – who you call, where you were – not about the content of communications. Historical analysis of the Western misconception of Aristotle’s Metaphysics explains how the Greek prefix meta falsely has come to imply hierarchy in our tech language today. With hierarchy comes classification: ‘it establishes an implicit system of control’. Boellstorff argues that such control creates the power to marginalize the actual implications of the program and conveniently obscure such aspects as scale – crucial to the debate as the extremely large scale of the data collection may reveal highly sensitive information about a person, organization or people, as Ed argued in his testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee.

Such rational arguments make perfect sense: it’s much more revealing to learn that I’ve called my shrink four times a week in the last four years, and four times on Christmas eve, than to know what I’ve actually said in a single conversation. But once you control the conceptualization of ‘metadata’, you influence public debate about the intelligence program. Not unlike most of our concepts,  ‘metadata’ is not a fact, it is made up. Subsequent re-conceptualization (Bruce Schneier: ‘metadata equals surveillance’) might make perfect sense, but becomes extremely hard and you find yourself on the defence.

Or take the concept of ‘big data’, a carefully constructed frame by proponents of systematic surveillance for commercial purposes. The concepts breathes a promise of a crystal ball and a solution for all problems of humankind. While careful theoretical examination of the concept of ‘big data’ is lacking, and in fact the trustworthiness or statistical quality of data analysis is often quite problematic, ‘big data’ has today become institutionalized, part of tech policy lingo and an attractive resource for research funding. Meanwhile, questioning ‘big data’ is to proponents the same as to reject modern life, to reject connecting with friends and, you know, world peace. Yes, we care about your privacy, but we need to solve the problem of aging first. The problem of aging, you mean the natural process that is part of us being humans?

In a ‘big data’ world, Boellstorff argues, ‘surveillance’ should not be understood through the lens of Orwell’s Big Brother or Foucault’s Panopticon. A more nuanced metaphor can be found in Foucault’s analysis of the confession, something Boellstorff in a brilliant part of the paper calls an ‘incitement to disclose’. This reminds of Barry Wellman’s networked individualism [pdf]: reject ‘big data’, and risk to be an outcast of your network – both socially and technically, you’re not part of the same systems if you don’t participate. Boellstorff terms this as a ‘dialectic of surveillance and recognition’, a dynamic that spurs a completely different set of trade-offs for users, than merely rejecting Big Brother or the Panopticon post-Snowden. If one follows Boellstorff, addressing surveillance requires a different set of policy responses than usual pleas for oversight, transparency and accountability of intelligence pratices. It illustrates that the many problems around surveillance should take the entire infrastructure for ‘big data’ into account, rather than only one institution or individual technology — as Joris van Hoboken aptly noted with regard to drones at last weeks Drone Conference in NYC.

Boellstorff mainly aims to raise theoretical questions about the underlying theory of our concepts, and to warn for carelessness when we talk concepts — because of their inherent politics of power and control. His ethnographic and anthropologic view on tech policy should be a source of introspection and inspiration for all involved in tech research and policy. If we really live in a ‘digital age’, research on the use of our concepts, such as the use of ‘privacy’ in various communities of computer scientists [see Claudia Lopez and Seda Gürses, IEEE P&S 2013, pdf], becomes increasingly important to flesh out the underlying incentives for framing the concepts in the way we do, sometimes even without fully realizing it.

‘Making up big data, in theory’ reminds us that concepts like ‘metadata’, ‘big data’ and ‘Big Brother’ that tech researchers and policymakers use on a daily basis are made up, and may be carefully constructed with a certain politics in mind. Beware of those politics — or would you rather notice someone sneaked in a good chunk of chili on your pizza after you’ve take a bite?

Thanks to fellow CITP Fellow Merlyna Lim for pointing me at this paper.

23 thoughts on “When an Ethnographer met Edward Snowden”

  1. Aweѕome websitе үouu have here but I was curious aboutiff yοu knew of any user discussion forums thаt cover the same topics disϲussedin this artіcle? I’d really love to be a art of community where I can ggеt advice fomother eⲭperienced people that share the same interest. If you have any recommendations,plеase let me know. Blesѕ you!

  2. I like what you guys are up also. Such clever work and reporting! Keep up the excellent works guys I have incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it’ll improve the value of my site 🙂

  3. A Parent’s Guide to Eczema.As a parent, you strive to give your child a happy and healthy life, but what if they suffer from eczema? The uncontrollable urge to itch and the unknown causes may be too much for you and your child to bear.As a parent, what are you to do?It is common to find rashes on children, but eczema is more than just a rash. It is skin condition that can turn into a struggle for both parents and children. You may have never heard of eczema until your child was diagnosed with it, but now what?Keep Your Child’s Skin Moisturized.There are different eczema trigger factors, which can lead to an outbreak.These trigger factors may include dust, stress, sweat, and laundry detergent.However, for some children, the cause is nothing more than dry skin. We instinctively want to touch and itch dry skin to provide relief and children do the same. Moisturize your child each day.Their itching may not completely cease, but you should notice an improvement.When moisturizing your child, aim for application throughout the day. However, the most important step is to moisturize their body immediately following a bath or shower. Your goal is to lock in the moisture.If your child is old enough, get them in the habit of reaching for moisturizer each time they feel the need to itch.Protect Your Child’s Skin.Eczema outbreaks are typically severe in small children.They don’t understand the complications that can arise from constant scratching; therefore, they continue to itch.If your child is old enough, have an eczema discussion with them. Encourage them to apply lotion or inform you whenever they feel the need to itch.However, for small children, such as toddlers and preschoolers, you need to protect your child’s skin yourself.As previously stated, the first line of protection is constant moisture. The second is to keep the area prone to outbreaks covered.This is especially important at night, as some children actually scratch their arms and legs in their sleep. When later asked, some are even unaware of their actions.The less direct contact the fingernails have with the skin, the less damage is done.Seek Medical Attention for Skin Infections.Most cases of eczema in children can be treated at home.However, children are at an increased risk for skin infections.Eczema creates the uncontrollable urge to itch. Your child may continue scratching until the skin is broken, leaving an open wound.Children will be children and that means coming into contact with many germs and bacteria.Combine these with an open wound and there is an increased risk for a skin infection.Treat your child’s eczema at home, but seek medical attention if you suspect the onset of infection.As a parent, you are unable to cure your child’s eczema, but you help protect them from the lifelong complications, such as scars.

  4. Does your website have a contact page? I’m having a tough time locating it
    but, I’d like to shoot you an email. I’ve got some suggestions for
    your blog you might be interested in hearing.
    Either way, great website and I look forward to seeing it
    improve over time.

  5. I’m amazed, I have to admit. Rarely do I come across a blog that’s both equally educative and amusing, and without a
    doubt, you have hit the nail on the head.

    The issue is an issue that too few men and women are speaking intelligently about.
    Now i’m very happy I came across this in my hunt for something relating to this.

  6. You are so interesting! I do not believe I have read through anything like this before.

    So wonderful to find someone with some unique thoughts on this
    topic. Seriously.. thanks for starting this up. This web site is one
    thing that is needed on the web, someone with
    a bit of originality!

  7. Simply desire to say your article is as surprising.
    The clearness in your post is just cool and i can assume you’re an expert on this subject.

    Fine with your permission let me to grab your feed to keep updated
    with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable

  8. Good day! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to
    give a quick shout out and say I truly enjoy reading through your articles.
    Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that cover
    the same topics? Thanks for your time!

  9. Nice weblog right here! Also your web site quite a bit up
    very fast! What web host are you using? Can I am getting your associate hyperlink in your
    host? I desire my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

Leave a Reply to Lucas Wojdak Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.