The 2008 Liberty Case: An Authoritive Ruling on Snowden’s Disclosures

Published 30 Oct. 2013 at Freedom to Tinker.

The other day, I was re-reading the 2008 Liberty vs. The United Kingdom ruling of the European Court of Human Rights (‘ECHR’). The case reads like any BREAKING / REVEALED news report on Edward Snowden’s disclosures, and will play a crucial role in the currently pending court cases in Europe on the legality of the surveillance programs. Liberty is also great material for comparing surveillance jurisprudence across the Atlantic.

They did not like what they saw on the telly in 1999. A TV show reported on the UK Ministry of Defence operated Electronic Test Facility (“ETF”) at Capenhurst in Cheshire. Soon afterwards, Liberty, the Irish Council for Civil Liberties and several other British NGOs launched a case against the UK government. The NGOs had provided legal advice throughout the UK during the 1990s and had legitimate concerns to be victims of the reported systematic mass surveillance of all telecommunications across the British isles.

After going upstream through several legal procedures, the ECHR released its final ruling in August 2008. Allow me to cherrypick from the Court’s assessment, in particular §64-§66:

  1. the 1985 Act [on which the UK government based its surveillance program] allowed the executive an extremely broad discretion … virtually unfettered;
  2. for example, all commercial submarine cables having one terminal in the UK and carrying external commercial communications to Europe;
  3. Information could be … listened to or read, if the Secretary of State considered this was required in the interests of national security, the prevention of serious crime or the protection of the United Kingdom’s economy;
  4. material was selected for examination by an electronic search engine, and search terms, falling within the broad categories covered by the [surveillance order] certificates, were selected and operated by officials.

The ruling has lots and lots of interesting observations, but these cherries square quite nicely with the Guardian reports on Snowden’s GCHQ disclosures on the TEMPORA program, as well as disclosures about xKeyscore, the mapping of a social graph of every internet user and the unfettered character of intelligence surveillance legal framework in general.

Since the first Snowden revelations, several cases have been launched — among them a fresh Liberty complaint and one by a second group of NGOs. When those cases end up upstream with the ECHR, and the NGOs have already committed to go all the way, Liberty will play a huge role in the Court’s assessment. So what was the outcome in 2008?

The short version: the Court struck the surveillance practises down for not being ‘in accordance with the law’. In other words, the legislation on which the British Government based its untargeted surveillance was so vague and ambiguous, that it didn’t meet the procedural requirements for surveillance laws under the European Convention of Human Rights – thus a violation of Liberty’s privacy rights.

Failing to meet the first procedural test, the Court was able to avoid the third, and politically much more sensitive, substantive test: was the 1990s ETF program ‘necessary in a democratic society?’ Given the sustained ambiguity in UK surveillance laws today, the Court just might be able to dance around the substantive assessment next time around. A likely outcome of such a case will be a legal necessity for meaningful oversight as well restraints on mass surveillance for Council of Europe member states with regard to their citizens.

Practically, if you think about it from a strategic game theory perspective, stronger domestic legal protection might just further fuel what you’ll read about today in the news and what we’ve argued last year in our paper ‘Obscured by Clouds’ (§2.2.3.): the circumvention of local laws through transnational surveillance followed by bilateral intelligence sharing, or ‘I spy from my country on your citizens, you from yours on my citizens, and we share the data through secret agreements’. That’s a difficult problem to solve under existing laws, unless we all agree about our universal commitment to the UN charter of human rights. Now there’s a political challenge.

A final thought: at least since 1978 (Klass v.  Germany), the ‘mere existence’ of vague surveillance laws is an actual harm, a violation of privacy. And for very good reasons, among them knowing what your government is up to and being able to protect senstive communications – such as NGOs providing legal advice to citizens. The US Supreme Court has taken a quite different approach a range of opinions, such as the February 2013 case of Clapper v. Amnesty [pdf]: no standing for Amnesty, the ACLU and other NGOs, as they couldn’t prove that they had been a subject of surveillance. Cunningly, meaningful transparency is just the sort of thing the Patriot Act and even more so the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act succeeds in obscuring.

A rather Orwellian twist in the Supreme Court case-law and the US legal framework. The mere existence of vague surveillance laws is dangerous in itself. Post-Snowden, one would hope that the Supreme Court catches on, in stead of moonwalking out of NGOs challenging government surveillance.

20 thoughts on “The 2008 Liberty Case: An Authoritive Ruling on Snowden’s Disclosures”

  1. I found the beginning much more compelling than the end — but where can you go after America’s most prominent architect is shot in the face by the jealous husband of a sexual conquest?Yinghui is an above-average success in business, but lonely in her personal lif.This book makes you feel like you’re capable of so much loving-kindness and goodness in the world around yo.She was very sweet and I loved her sisterly relationship which grows between her and Elizabet.His other characters lack depth to the point of caricature (such are Chemin the coward or the ignominious Talon) [url=]However, what I enjoyed the most[/url] For him, the Soviets were still “the July assassins” of Nicholas the Second, and Graham heard much of Finnish victories and Russian defeat.The ONLY thing that even kept me reading past book one was the last paragraph of the entire book when the kids found a grown-u. [url=]CELINE S’HABILLE TOUTE SEULE. Avec un CD[/url] the reason it is called ” A Boy Called duct Tape” is Pablo is very poor and just put duct tape on his tennis shoes since his family cannot afford new one.Mungkin penulis boleh share resipi karipap pusing Nek Jah@Wafeen yang menjadi favourite sepanjang zaman t. [url=]It turns out that Earth doesn’t[/url] The only reason it didn’t get 1 star was because I loved all Jenks, Ivy, and Newt/Al parts.All in all, I wasn’t impressed with the elf-heavy plot, everything Trent related, the cringey romance, and Rachel’s pathetic personality.Despite all this when her ward disappears without a trace Drake, the hero, sets out to help Charlotte find he. [url=]This book, like many of Kerouac’s[/url] “Steeped in the age-old beauty and traditions of Ireland, Dorien Kelly’s enchanting contemporary novel transports readers to a picturesque Irish village where passions run deep….”Miss Kylie “Soon-to-Be-a-Saint” O’Shea teaches at the Gaelic school, helps her neighbors and volunteers for every good caus.I didn’t think Harlequin let their authors run with such savage characterization and brutal imagery, but I’m glad they di. [url=]Alkisah karena kemenangan Sultan Alkadrie melawan[/url] The publisher should have subtitled this tone “Stories of Victorian Supernatural Suspense”He doesn’t seem restricted by any of the characters he presents either, but embodies his lonely, aging actresses, blase, lady-killer policemen, teenage lovers, and jaded, cynical detectives with the same aplom. [url=]There are plot twists, betrayals, loyalties,[/url] Full of unexpected twists, this book will keep you guessing until the very last page.Poverty is John (his guide) driving around in the Tanzanian night looking for the doctor while his daughter dies.”On the other hand, “Making money through hard work and wise investment is a fine thing to do.” And so it i. [url=]You really don’t need to have[/url] The ensuing conflicts take the reader along on a vicarious experience with a compelling group of character.Marisa CheneryMarisa Chenery was always a lover of books, but after reading her first historical romance novel she found herself hooke. [url=]Transhumanisme – A la limite des valeurs humanistes[/url] But as suitor after suitor fails to inspire her love, or her desire, she is certain she will never find a man who touches her deepl.They are about a private eye-turned-vampire in 1930’s Chicago, and they are quite entertaining, or at least I remember them as suc. [url=]juliesbookreview.blogspot.comNext of Sin byLisa GordonA[/url] On the one hand, this novel reads like a caricature of The Godfather, like the fantasy of someone who has watched one too many Martin Scorsese movie.This is what wiki says about this man Howard Phillips Lovecraft (August 20, 1890 – March 15, 1937) — known as . [url=]Kin biologie[/url] Unlike many other trilogies, however, this is set on a different world with different people.And when she runs for class president, the animals cause hilarious disasters which may turn her plans upside down! [url=]Good deal – I want to[/url] A new addition just came out to print, so most bookstores should have i.I think that George VI was a very admirable man and was a very good kin. [url=]I particularly like the opening of[/url] Noah shut his family and animals in a cave to escape the scourge of disease, the same disease that the bad guys have harvested and want to use on the rest of the world.With a title like The Ark, I actually wanted more biblical focus on the ark and the flood myth in different cultures, but there wasn’t enough of thi.Nur ein maskierter Fremder stellt sich den Gefahren unbekГјmmert mit seinem Schwert entgege. [url=]I’m not a religious person so[/url] However, here it also becomes clear that he constantly steers being into human thought, which is hardly explained and thus becomes trivial.Wallander’s hunt for the girl’s identity and his furious pursuit of a killer who scalps his victims will throw him and those he loves most into mortal danger. [url=]Karan is penitent he once humiliated[/url] She has not had a normal life, being raised with and working with mercenaries, and is ignorant of male/female relationships.Daniel / Nitro raised on an Indian reservation – his father, an artist, was abusive when he drank… Nitro joined the army at 16 (lied) to get away from him, and to take away the main reason his parents fought… he did not return home after his first tour, and his father killed his mother (by accident) in a fit of drunken rage – and is in priso.To compound the difficulties faced by these kids, teachers tens to discipline them for their bullying behaviors while blaming them when they are victimize. [url=]The plot is very character driven[/url] Elise tells how, with courage, fortitude, and faith— holding fast to her beloved’s memory and his promise that she and the children would always be loved and cared for—she eventually finds her way home to be with her loved ones once again.In A Promise Kept the author reaches out to other survivors of tragic loss, in hopes that by reliving her experiences, they will re-live their own, yet come away with the strength and courage needed to face, to accept, and to begin their own grief journey, regardless of the nature of their los.I loved reading about her childhood and home life and her other interests besides music (i.. [url=]When their relationship changes gears from[/url] This is either the highest compliment or the highest criticism, depending on what you want to take with yo.As student Claire Danvers and her friends prepare to defend Morganville against the elements – both natural and unnatural – the unexpected happens: Morganville’s vampires begin to vanish one by on. [url=]Man erfГ¤hrt mehr Гјber Rick Blaines[/url] This section has some really interesting stuff on Marxism, the English Civil war and Pilgrims Progress.Chapter 3 deals with problems many historians fail to see in their writings and that is the problem of anachronis.I think that one of the great things about this memoir is that there’s no sense of anticlimax during the portions of his memoir that are combat fre. [url=]ASTM E 756-05 – Standard test method for measuring vibration-damping properties of materials[/url] Sarah Hardestyaka:Jill MarchNora RobertsEleanor Marie Robertson was born on October 10, 1950 in Silver Spring, Maryland, US.A Collars & Cuffs StorySince the death of his submissive lover two years ago, Leo hasn’t been living—merely existin.Abraham cannot explain everything, but can he not explain why he cannot explain? Perhaps Silentio would say that giving such an explanation is a temptation, a weaknes.This color is an ongoing theme throughout the book, with the text and the grapes and also the end pages of the boo.All likeable characters, which have been in previous books I think, but just too sugary for me, hence I didn’t read the second story.]

  2. Пополение баланса Авито (Avito) за 50 | Телеграмм @a1garant Мое почтение, дорогие друзья! Будем рады предоставить Всем вам сервис по пополнению баланса на действующие активные аккаунты Avito (а также, совершенно новые). Если Вам требуются определенные балансы – пишите, будем решать. Потратить можно на турбо продажи, любые платные услуги Авито (Avito). Аккаунты не Брут. Живут долго. Процент пополнения в нашу сторону и стоимость готовых аккаунтов: 50 от баланса на аккаунте.Если требуется залив на ваш аккаунт, в этом случае требуются логин и пароль Вашего акка для доступа к форме оплаты, пополнения баланса.Для постоянных заказчиков гибкая система бонусов и скидок!Гарантия: И, конечно же ничто не укрепляет доверие, как – Постоплата!!! Вперед денег не просим… А также, гасим Штрафы ГИБДД за 65 … Оплата:ЯндексДеньги, Webmoney (профессиональные счета)Рады сотрудничеству! Залив Авито канал Телеграмм ________ авито купить буаккаунты авито +с балансомавито авто +с пробегом бесплатнобесплатная недвижимость авитоскидки +на авито +на услуги

  3. Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this website before but after looking at some of the posts I realized it’s new
    to me. Regardless, I’m certainly delighted I discovered it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back frequently!

  4. I’ll right away take hold of your rss as I can’t find your e-mail subscription link or newsletter service.
    Do you’ve any? Kindly permit me realize so that I could subscribe.


  5. It is not my first time to visit this site, i am visiting this website dailly and obtain pleasant information from here everyday.

  6. Thanks for giving your ideas. I’d personally also like to mention that video games have been ever before evolving. Technology advances and revolutions have aided create realistic and enjoyable games. These kinds of entertainment video games were not actually sensible when the actual concept was first being used. Just like other areas of technological innovation, video games also have had to grow via many years. This is testimony towards fast continuing development of video games.

  7. I’ll right away grab your rss feed as I can not in finding your email subscription hyperlink or newsletter service.
    Do you have any? Kindly permit me recognise in order that
    I may subscribe. Thanks.

  8. I’ve observed that in the world today, video games are classified as the latest fad with kids of all ages. There are occassions when it may be difficult to drag young kids away from the activities. If you want the best of both worlds, there are numerous educational gaming activities for kids. Great post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.